A Car Runs 2.5 Kilometers with 1.5 eu Worth of Gasoline
Many of you would say that a cars' fuel efficiency is nothing new.
The cars currently available (passenger-cars with gasoline engines)
run 12.3 kilometers per liter on the average (for 10.15 mode, 1993),
which is 2.9 kilometers per eu in an Ecological Unit. In reality, fuel
efficiency tends to be less than that in theory and is assumed to be
about 2.5 kilometers per eu.
In the late 1970s, Japanese car manufacturers struggled to develop fuel
efficient cars in order to meet the emission control requirements stipulated
by Muskie Act of the United States. Such efforts led to improvements
in fuel efficiency and the quality of cars, making the Japanese automobiles
highly competitive around the world. This is still talked as a good
example, for it shows that environmental measures do not necessarily
suppress economic growth .
Now, a question. Are the Japanese cars really fuel efficient? The actual
energy required for a car to transport passengers is 572 kcal per passenger
and kilometer (which is, in terms of gasoline, equivalent to about 15
kilometers per liter). This is four times higher than the energy required
by a bus and twelve times that of a railway. Let's consider the reasons
why the fuel efficiency of cars remains unimproved and what can be done
about that.
- Roads Being Congested
This is the reason why the Japanese Government directs most of its
expenditure for global warming measures into road construction, which
is considered to be effective in helping the problem of traffic congestion.
Road improvement could certainly be a help if it does not create more
traffic. But in reality, it does. Thus, the problem of congestion
is likely to remain unsolved as long as such a vicious cycle continues.
Many countries are taking measures to reduce traffic. For example,
in Mexico City, the authorities are testing a pilot traffic control
scheme under which cars with only either odd or even license plate
numbers are allowed in the city center at a particular time. In Germany,
the government is carrying out a policy of reassessing railways and
encouraging car passengers to switch to railways by introducing substantial
cuts in the railway pass rates. In Japan, too, the "Park & Ride" campaign
is being put to a test in Kamakura. This was designed to encourage
car passengers who wish to travel into the city center to park their
cars in the car parks just outside the city center and then switch
to a railway or a bus. In addition, traffic information will soon
be made available through car navigation systems. Every Japanese car
manufacturer appears to be working out a plan for a future transportation
system which makes automatic driving feasible.
- Most Cars Carry Only One Passenger
Most cars carry only one or two passengers, although they can carry
up to four . There is no wonder why fuel efficiency remains unimproved
if we run a lump of iron weighing about 1.5 tons just to transport
one passenger, who weighs only about 70 kilograms. In Singapore, there
are restrictions on the free entry to the city center by one- passenger
cars, while Los Angeles has secured a traffic lane for cars carrying
more than one passenger. The issue of the one-passenger car can be
really thorny, as it concerns a charm inherent to cars - that is to
say, a person can hop in it and go off whenever he or she likes.
- Actual Fuel Efficiency Is Falling
The Fuel efficiency of Japanese cars peaked in 1998, followed by a
continual decline due to increasing consumer tastes for big and expensive
cars, as well as the car weight increase incurred by the obligatory
installment of safety equipment. Furthermore and ironically, recreational
vehicles, which have a high displacement volume and consume more fuel,
continue to be selling well compared to fuel efficient cars for which
considerable development efforts were made. It can be assumed that
whether fuel efficiency improves or not depends on consumer awareness.
In the meantime, it is necessary to provide an incentive for consumers
who choose fuel efficient cars, by taking some measures like the introduction
of carbon tax, and so on
Fuel Efficient Cars Run 6.7 kilometers per 1 eu Worth of Fuel
The State of California in the United States instituted a regulation
concerning zero emission vehicles (which emit no fumes) and low emission
vehicles (which emit less toxic fumes). The regulation stipulates that
a certain percentage of vehicles sold in and after the enforcement date
must be zero or low emission vehicles. In order to sustain business
operations, every car manufacturer around the world is developing low
pollution and fuel efficient cars, aiming to satisfy the requirements
of the law. In the meantime, car manufacturers are considering possible
future measures which might be taken in relation to exhaust fumes and
global warming.
The zero emission vehicles currently available consist of "Electric
Vehicles" only. It is said that one power station uses zero emission
vehicles, while emitting exhaust gas through its operation. However,
electric vehicles still have some disadvantages such as long charge
hours, driving range and price.
The "Fuel Cell Electric Vehicle", which is now under development by
every car manufacturer, generates electricity through a chemical reaction
by using hydrogen or ethanol (a reverse reaction of water electrolysis).
As fuel cell electric vehicles do not need to be charged, they can be
used in the same way as conventional cars. Not only that, but also the
only exhaust emission is steam. They are expected to be the favorite
among the future vehicles.
Toyota's Prius, a hybrid vehicle which was launched at the end of last
year, combines the best of the gasoline-fueled cars and the electric
vehicles. It is not a zero emission vehicle as it uses gasoline engine.
However, the engine operates only when its burning efficiency is high.
While in motion, the electric motor is used as the generator to charge
the battery so that it can assist the engine when its burning efficiency
gets low. Thus, energy-conservation and low- pollution driving are realized
without charging. Prius runs 28 kilometers per liter (10.15 mode), which
is as twice the fuel efficiency of other cars of comparable performance.
In the Ecological Unit, its fuel efficiency is 6.7 kilometers per eu.
The target set by the European car manufacturers, which is 100 kilometers
per three liters, is only a step away for it.
It can be said that cars have been the very dream of mankind of the
20th century in which oil civilization has flourished. It seems that
we still have a desire to hold onto cars, even if that means most of
our income is spent on their loans and maintenance. We just can't give
up cars despite the fact that 14,000 deaths were caused annually by
traffic accidents in Japan alone and our awareness that cars offer no
prospects for improving air pollution.
It is inevitable that petroleum resources will be exhausted in the next
century. Unless fuel efficiency improves to the level of 100 kilometers
per liter or so, or inexpensive zero emission vehicles are successfully
developed, the 21st century can offer no hope for cars. It truly is
difficult to give up a dream.
Written by Shinji Yagi
Reference and Notes
- Statistical data on energy:
- "Energy Conservation Handbook" by The Energy Conservation
Center, Japan and other sources. Then calculation is based on the
formula ; 1 liter of gasoline = 8400 kcal = 4.2 eu. A list of fuel
efficiency and CO2 emission for each car type can be viewed at the
Environment Partnership Plaza(www.geic.or.jp/choco2/)
- Measures for traffic congestion:
- "World Resources and Environment, 1996-1997" compiled
by Sekai Shigen Kenkyujo and others (Published by Chuo Hoki)
- Electric vehicle:
- Toyota's RAV4 is priced at 4,950,000 yen. There
still remains a possibility that electric vehicle will become the
favorite among the zero emission vehicles in the future, if highly
powerful batteries are successfully developed. In order for such
vehicles to become widespread, charging stations must be placed
nationwide. Issues concerning power stations also need to be considered.
- Prius:
- According to Toyota, its Prius has been selling
well, despite the car's fixed price of 2,150,000 yen which barely
makes a profit. Its fuel efficiency, as reported by various sources,
varies from 15 to 20 kilometers per liter. This means that fuel
efficiency varies depending on driving conditions. A hybrid vehicle
(1) is quiet when in motion in a residential area during the nighttime,
(2) shows its power when in motion in an urban area as a regenerative
braking system operates to recover energy, and (3) can work with
any type of engine. Because of these advantages, if made into a
taxi, we can boast of its performance to the world.
- Other hybrid vehicles:
- Nissan and Honda also plan to launch hybrid vehicles.
Honda's hybrid vehicle is a light weight sports car type which uses
a capacitor instead of a battery and with a fuel efficiency of 30
kilometers per liter. GM and Chrysler also exhibited their version
of hybrid vehicles at the motor show. Despite the assumption that
hybrid vehicles would make no profits due to the inexpensive gasoline
price in the United States, Toyota is in the process of developing
a large edition of Prius, targeted at the North American market.
Hino's parallel hybrid bus has long been available, but without
success.
- Other fuel efficient vehicles:
- It is claims that the direct injection gasoline
engine (e.g. Mitsubishi's GDI and Toyota's D4) has been achieved
30% better fuel efficiency. The direct diesel engine (Isuzu's DD)
is said to have achieved a 60% improvement in fuel efficiency, which
is surprising if it is true. But the truth is that it has 60% better
fuel efficiency compared to "gasoline engine cars".
- Low pollution:
- It is often said that Japanese cars have no problems
with the strict emission regulations. However, the environmental
standards which control nitrogen oxide emission have long gone unobserved
due to an increase in the number of cars. In a few years to come
from this autumn, emission regulations are to be tightened gradually.
The industry has set the objective of a 30% improvement in fuel
efficiency in order to tackle the problem of global warming. The
environmental technological race among car manufacturers, which
might determine their future, is expected to begin soon.
- Improvement in fuel efficiency:
- Takeo Saito (Professor at Tohoku University) says in his book
"Heat Island" (published by Kodansha, Blue Backs) that 100 kilometers
per liter should be achieved. For instance, the best record marked
at the "Honda Econo Power Fuel Efficiency Race" is 3,014,715 kilometers
per liter. This means that the car can go 718 kilometers, which
is equivalent to the distance from Tokyo to near Aomori, by consuming
only 1 eu worth of energy. This is only an impracticable calculation.
Even so, the 17th century poet Basho, who wrote about his journeys
between the two regions would no doubt be surprised if he knew.
- No hope for cars:
- "Can the Eco-Car Save the Future?" by Koji Misaki (published by
Diamondsha) discusses every technological possibility for the new
generation cars and concludes that none of them would be reliable.
The author proposes that we should build up a society in which we
need fewer cars. As the author is a former engineer who specialized
in car development, his writing has tremendous persuasive power.
- Environmental effects:
- Apart from the energy issue and air pollution, there are other
aspects that must be considered in relation to the environmental
effects of cars. It is necessary to consider more about (1) the
broader aspects which include not only the cars themselves but also
the environmental destruction caused by road improvement, and (2)
the way we scrap cars only after seven years' having them in service
and so discard a mass of industrial waste such as harmful shredder
dust--so, we undoubtedly can't afford to continue as we did.
|